| More
Showing posts with label Internships. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Internships. Show all posts

Sunday, 13 May 2012

Adopt an Intern promoted in the Highlands by graduates


Two graduate interns have been recruited in the Highlands to spread the word about a nationwide Adopt an Intern programme that offers unemployed graduates paid work experience.
Eilidh Finlayson and Gemma Gentles have begun a paid three-month internship to promote the programme and help attract graduates and interested organisations.
Adopt an Intern was created by the Centre for Scottish Public Policy (CSPP), an independent think-tank, in January 2010. The programme gained Scottish Government funding in March of that year.
However, these two new internships have been made possible by the Highland Council through an Innovation Challenge Grant of just under £10,000 for which the programme successfully applied.
The council agreed to supply desk space for the graduates, as well as some useful guidance from its staff in the planning and development service department.
The graduate interns are busy meeting with key public agencies and businesses across the region to encourage them to employ a graduate for a minimum of three months and up to one year.
The Adopt an Intern team are dispersed throughout Scotland. They provide a free recruitment and shortlisting service to help make the process as cost-effective as possible for the host organisation.
To date, they have placed 153 graduates, 12 of them in the Highlands and islands.
The interns have already met careers service staff at the University of the Highlands and Islands and all UHI graduates will be advised of the opportunities presented by the programme.
Eilidh and Gemma are both graduates of Edinburgh University.
Eilidh said: “Having been looking for graduate employment in the Highlands, where I was born and brought up, I have experienced how few opportunities there are for graduates and how difficult it is to get a job close to home.
“To find a job, graduates first need experience in the workplace and the Adopt an Intern programme provides this important opportunity, as well as promoting a paid internship culture in Scotland.”
Gemma said: “It would be great if public agencies and private businesses take part in the programme and help job-seeking Highland graduates gain vital work experience near their homes, keeping local talent local.
“The programme has already witnessed the positive benefit this brings to local businesses and organisations alike. Our own internship is much appreciated and will give Eilidh and I important experience in project management.”
The council’s director of planning and development, Stuart Black, said: “The Highland Council recognises the challenge of graduate unemployment at the current time.
“The Adopt an Intern programme is an important way of tackling this issue and we were pleased to support the CSPP with their project in the Highlands.”
Source: Pressandjournal.co.uk, Friday 11th May 2012

Saturday, 12 May 2012

Internships: with age comes the search for experience

The number of interns over 25 is rising, but while maturity brings expertise – and benefits the economy – apprentices face a number of age-related issues.



A tuft of grey chest hair pokes out of the top of Alan Kean's stripey shirt. It catches my eye as we drink tea amid the deafening chatter and the expensive fig trees in Portcullis House where Alan, 55, is six months into life as a parliamentary intern.
In recent months there has been much gnashing of teeth over young people flooding into these positions, unpaid or poorly paid, with scant observation of working rights, desperate to get a foot on the career ladder. That has left little room for discussion around a lesser-known trend: of the 457,200 apprentice positions started in 2010-11 in the UK, 182,100 were started by people aged 25 or over, according to the Data Service. Five years ago, only 300 people aged 25 or older took up these roles.
Of the overall rise between 2006-7 and 2010-11, 68% were in the 25-plus age group, according to the National Audit Office (NAO); an increase it attributes to Tony Blair's government, which, in 2003, widened the age eligibility criteria for government-funded, private company-run apprenticeships to include over 25s.
Many people presume that interning, or being an apprentice (the two are used almost interchangeably) is for graduates or school leavers only and the newly-launched National Careers Service doesn't disabuse would-be applicants of that notion.
Jobs websites bring up advert after advert seeking "ambitious graduates" with a "work hard, play hard attitude" to fill numerous unpaid or minimum-wage internships and apprenticeships – wording that barely complies with age-discrimination law and makes plain the cultural advantage younger, cheaper applicants have over older ones. Part of the problem is that the National Apprenticeships Service pays up to 100% of the training cost of placements taken by 16-18 year olds, and up to 50% for ages 19-24, but makes only an unspecified "contribution" for placements taken by those aged 25 or over.
"The impression is that the government doesn't provide routes for older people like that. We know there's no such thing as a job for life anymore, but culturally, we're yet to develop that broader attitude," says Rosemary Thomas, a research assistant at the Work Foundation, previously a work psychologist at Jobcentre Plus.
"At Jobcentre Plus I worked with lots of long-term unemployed, or over-25s that hadn't worked out what they wanted to do. An apprenticeship or internship would have been a perfect solution for them, but it was so hard to come across anything. We tended to guide them down the voluntary route."
What kind of people make "mature interns"? A Leicestershire boy who left school with no qualifications, Kean fell into hotel work and meandered through "low administrative level" jobs in the NHS and the local branch of the Department for Work and Pensions, later working in the community football stadium in Doncaster where he and his wife relocated, before moving again to London. After a short employment contract with Harrods, he worked as a volunteer with Locog interviewing other potential Olympics volunteers. Then he saw that the Social Mobility Foundation was offering nine-month internships working for parliamentarians, paying £17,500 for that period.
"I did wonder if I was too old to apply because most interns are 18-25, aren't they?" says Kean. "Once upon a time someone like me would be at the end of their working life. But I'm not ready to lie down," he adds. "Like most working-class people I've not had a career, but I've shown in my work that I can do almost anything – I'm flexible and the labour market has a need for that. Being stuck in a rut is a luxury of years gone by. The more strings you have to your bow, the easier it should be to find paid work."
The forthcoming rise in retirement age makes refreshing your skills and competitiveness important. And while older interns and apprentices are doing that, they're providing the UK taxpayer with value for money. In a February 2012 report, scrutinising the government's apprenticeship programme, the NAO found that its advanced and intermediate apprenticeship models produce returns of respectively £21 and £16 for every pound of public funding they receive (the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills estimates those returns at respectively £24 and £35, using a different calculation).
At 27, Ben Harford is an older intern, one of many thousands trying to break into the creative industries, where, though much criticised, poorly-paid internships are all but mandatory. Redundancy last Christmas brought a small sum of cash that Ben ploughed into a career change, retraining from public sector administration to graphic design. A Gumtree advertisement led him to a full-time internship designing sponsorship collateral for a Premiership football club. The commute costs him £500 a month, taking up most of his minimum-wage salary, and he relies on his girlfriend's income to shore up their living expenses.
The work is enjoyable, says Ben, but could end at any time. "It was meant to be six weeks, but it always gets extended for another week, another two weeks … they keep their cards close to their chest, so you're always in limbo," he says. "In this industry you've got to earn your stripes by working for not much money. Even junior positions expect one year's experience. So you've got to start with an internship." His fellow interns, most of whom graduated last summer, "have rich boyfriends or live at home rent-free – they can enjoy being 21 and survive on the minimum wage with their parents' backup. They don't have the responsibilities I've got."
But it can work. Mike Mann was 39 when he joined Pricewaterhouse Coopers' Headstart scheme in 2007 – its equivalent to a graduate scheme, but for those without many formal qualifications – leaving behind a long-established career in sound production. Apprentices are paid a salary to work full-time and study for their accounting qualifications.
He now manages audits for the businesses he was attached to when he started. "I was fed up working in an environment where we were incredibly experienced technically and commercially, but had no real business understanding. I wanted to understand what makes businesses succeed and felt strongly that I needed a mixture of hands-on work and formal training," says Mann. "It was very daunting at first, but being in an environment where everyone is enthusiastic about learning is so refreshing."
He adds that one of his oddest apprenticeship experiences was revising for exams at the kitchen table alongside his daughters who were studying for their GCSEs and AS levels: "Not what you expect to be doing at 40."
The Headstart scheme pays between £16,000 and £20,000. Can an older apprentice survive on that? "This has been the hardest part, but in less than five years I'm back to a healthy salary and over the next few years it will easily surpass what I could have earned before changing career," Mann says.
The NAO report says that completing an advanced apprenticeship is associated with raising earning power by 18%, and completing an intermediate internship raises salaries by 11%.
The cultural barrier to older people accessing these positions remains strong. Some think employers presume they will want too much money, defend their workers' rights too strongly or even show them up professionally. "Employers might be put off because they think they'll expect lots of money, but they might have come out of a well-paid career and aren't motivated by money any more," says Rosemary Thomas.
Kean, the oldest participant on the parliamentary interns scheme, agrees. "So many MPs and their interns have no expertise and haven't worked anywhere else, so I've brought in some procedures here to make things run smoothly," he says. "But I think some employers might be intimidated by someone a bit older with a mind of their own like that. We're more likely to stand up for ourselves, while young workers are new to the workplace and don't know what's expected of them – which is why they are abused."
The government intends to invest more in apprenticeships, and given the return on investment older participants appear to provide, it makes sense to give them more funding.
But Chris Ball, chief executive of The Age Employment Network, sees the cultural blockade at its strongest within the government's apprenticeship machinery. "There are huge issues around economic inactivity among older people, and the fact is the government has put far more energy into supporting young workers than older workers," he says.
"Older people need to feel there is somebody out there working for them, but they're just not a priority – they have to wait six months before they're allowed onto the Work Programme, in which time demoralisation and self-pity can set in. You'll look like a far better prospect to an employer if you're doing something like interning than if you're out of work."

Case study: the translator

Well travelled and multi-lingual, Marta Rodriguez, 34, is the epitome of the progressive European prepared for tomorrow's labour market. A BA twice over, and currently studying an online Master's degree as a mature student, she is highly experienced in translation work.
She is halfway through a six-month internship with a west London translation company, on a scheme operated by the European commission which aims to "help students to adapt to the requirements of the EU-wide labour market".
For Marta, it's a shrewd way to see how her translation clients work from the inside while getting paid. The position was advertised unpaid except for €500 for living costs. But Marta got lucky: her employers pay her £500 per month on top. "They're happy because I think they were expecting an intern with whom they had to spend a lot of time teaching and explaining things."
Marta is the agency's first intern and is seven years older than her manager.
"At the beginning they thought I'd be working on their database all day long, but I'm translating, I'm proof-reading translations from our freelance translators, and I'm about to do some project management," she explains.
"They weren't expecting me to be as experienced as I am or to know what I'm doing. They can rely on me and delegate things.
"I hadn't even thought about the possibility of being an intern before. I thought my employer Erasmus wouldn't accept me because of my age – that they might think 'oh, she must be a loser'," Marta admits.
"That's about my preconceptions – that there's an established way. You finish university, you do your internship, then you get a job, you get a better job and that is what you do with your life – so I thought that was how society would behave towards me."
Source: Melanie Stern, Guardian.co.uk, Friday 11th May 2012

Saturday, 3 March 2012

Internships can be a chance to test the water

“I was working three jobs and living in a bedsit. I was really poor and lonely and knew I needed to get out.” University of York graduate Charlie Elliot, 23, experienced the difficulties many students face after their degrees – the city they’ve called home for several years feels suddenly remote, while they remain unsure about how to begin a career or what to do with their new qualifications.

Her solution was to find an internship. She moved home and spent nine months working in the marketing department of a London law firm and now works as a social media executive.

“I knew I wanted to do marketing but I didn’t work out that I wanted to do social media until I’d been working for a little while,” she says. “The internship helped me focus.”

In a crowded job market, internships and graduate training schemes are becoming increasingly important.

Although there have been recent concerns over pay, they remain useful ways for graduates and career changers to gain experience and skills without investing in further academic qualifications, and are also attractive to employers. “Graduate training schemes and internships are extremely valuable to both the job seekers and businesses we work with,” says Michael Gentle, head of B2C marketing, Monster UK and Ireland. “They give employers the chance to test drive potential future employees and train new graduates from scratch.”

Schemes can last from a matter of weeks to several years. Naturally candidates might look for a programme related to their ideal career, or run by a dream employer, but it’s equally valid to look for schemes that will get them into work and picking up skills.

In the case of Network Rail’s new Track and Train scheme candidates work in various customer service related roles throughout the company over 18 months. “We wanted to help graduates,” explains professional development manager Linsey Perry, “to give them a chance to get some solid experience on their CVs.”

This approach can benefit recent graduates and career changers alike. Karl Grewar left a six year career in media to join the Network Rail Operations Management Graduate Scheme. “The aim is to expose you to as many aspects of the operational railway as possible,” he explains. “You end up seeing the world in a totally different light.”

Likewise, Elliot found that her broad internship was very helpful. In addition to learning the basics of marketing she helped her lawyer colleagues discover Twitter and LinkedIn. “That was the tipping point for my CV,” she says, as she was able to mention her experience on job applications and at interview.

To begin searching for a placement graduates can head to both mainstream recruiters and dedicated websites specialising in internships and graduate training schemes. There are other avenues to explore too: the Track and Train scheme was advertised through Job Centre Plus, while Elliot saw her internship posted on noticeboard site Gumtree.com.

Having identified a prospective scheme, there’s the matter of securing a place. “Competition is fierce so it’s crucial that students focus on building up their employability skills throughout university,” says Les Rees, director of careers and employer services at Cardiff University. He recommends current students get involved in extracurricular activities, find work experience if possible, and prepare themselves for testing times ahead. “The recruitment process will be tough so make sure you know what to expect and take part in practice interviews and tests.”

A further challenge is getting paid, which remains a controversial issue as there’s no guarantee that an internship will cover more than lunch expenses.

While manageable for some, it’s impossible for others. Gentle argues that businesses shouldn’t take advantage of graduates’ desperation, since internships “have proven benefits for both the employer and job seeker,” and stresses that paid schemes are out there. “Candidates must be proactive and knock on doors to uncover these sorts of opportunities.”

Source: Russ Thorne, Independent.co.uk, Friday 2nd March 2012

Sunday, 20 November 2011

Internships: exploring new ways into work

For the 1.5 million under-35s currently unemployed, there has never been a better time to find work than in this recession. The problem is almost of all it seems to be unpaid. From the websites of private companies to the government's own job board, Graduate Talent Pool, adverts abound for unpaid work experience and internships.

From politics to media and fashion, the traditional "hot jobs" where demand outstrips the possible supply, young graduates and school-leavers are being targeted in an unprecedented way. Luxury brands such as Stella McCartney and Harrods beckon to today's bright young things offering a few weeks, sometimes even months, of experience. They suggest there is the opportunity to gain unprecedented access to the inside workings of their businesses. But when you dig a little deeper, what are these placements actually offering?

Scanning the posts on the Interns Anonymous website, some internships appear to be as dull and dreary as the worst clerical office job, except without the monthly salary. Other posts, though, offer a perfect introduction to the world of work and ultimately a job with the company you've grown to love working for. The biggest sticking point is always pay. It means that only a few can afford to get on the ladder to employment leaving a rump of poorer people behind.

Quintessentially – a "concierge" company co-founded by Tom Parker Bowles, which organises the lives of the rich and famous – has recently admitted to not paying their interns. The company argues that not only do a good proportion of their interns receive jobs with the company after their stint, but that "all tasks are given with a view to improve the intern's understanding of the industry, provide value for their CV, or develop their skills in their chosen sector." However, when asked exactly what was so rewarding, they describe the interns' tasks as "filing documents, assisting with mail and collecting marketing materials".

But internships can be done very differently. The publishing house Penguin says it pays all its interns – a policy that has come down directly from the CEO, Tom Weldon. It even pays expenses for those who do two weeks of shadowing. Paying the minimum wage – this rose to £6.08 an hour for over- 21s on 1 October – can not only mean all the difference to those seeking out work – it can also be a real boon to the company itself.

Penguin's HR executive Ellie Pike says that it would be easy to fill its four 10-week placements with the children of wealthy parents, but argues the company would ultimately suffer as a result.

"Publishing is meant to be a diverse industry," she says. "We publish a wide range of authors and we want a wide range of experience and background from our staff for the business to be successful. I don't think it would do us much good to just have a small minority of the population working here."

However, internships are a positive experience for some people. Gina Reay, 22, works in PR in Harrogate, and had two unpaid internships after she left university. The second led to a full-time job: "I used the experience as an opportunity to prove I was talented and committed and, thankfully, my hard work paid off!" says Reay. "It is an invaluable way to get noticed and, in my opinion, simply a prolonged interview process from an employer's perspective."

There is another push to make sure internships are the work trials they promise to be, rather than cheap ways of businesses getting free labour. After the deputy prime minister, Nick Clegg, made ending the culture of unpaid internships part of his social mobility strategy this spring, attention has also been focused on the fact that unpaid internships can be deemed a breach of national minimum-wage law.

Judges in recent employment cases have taken the side of interns over employers. Keri Hudson, 21, won more than £1,000 in back-pay after she worked unpaid for six weeks as an intern at the My Village entertainment reviews company. With help from the National Union of Journalists' "cashback for interns" campaign, Hudson scored a victory against the company in May after she claimed to have "practically run the company" alongside a multitude of other unpaid interns.

Becky Heath, from campaigning group Internocracy, has been consulting with companies to make work experience better and more productive for employers and young people alike. She is currently helping to advise the government on drawing up a gold standard on what work experience should be like – but getting the message through can be hard.

"We were at a roundtable event with Nick Clegg's office, the CBI and other employer organisations, and some of the things we were saying about young people's [internship] experiences were completely alien to them," she says.

In mid-September, the Department of Business, Innovation and Skills published new guidance on pay which Heath says includes lots of helpful examples on who "should and shouldn't get paid" under the law. However, Heath adds, "What we're not seeing is the government committing to crack down on intern employers who don't pay which is disappointing."

The other major route into employment is an apprenticeship. These government-backed schemes, mainly targeted at school-leavers rather than graduates, are far more structured than internships in the way they develop skills. And thanks to an increase in government funding and ministerial backing, they are enjoying a boom. There is currently enough money to train 360,000 apprentices. The downside is that for those aged 16-18, pay is just £2.60 an hour and there is no ultimate guarantee of a job. But given the rises in tuition fees and the cutting of the educational maintenance allowance, this earn-while-you-learn system, much unloved by past administrations, could become the route of choice for those finishing GCSEs.

There are no easy answers to getting young people back into work. But despite a reputation for being feckless and living off the bank of mum and dad, young people are achieving – the statistics on educational attainment suggest that today's youth are the best educated in British history. They are also the most computer literate and, if given the chance, perhaps the most innovative. What everyone agrees is that they deserve a fair break.

Source: Shiv Malik, Guardian.co.uk, Saturday 19th November 2011

Friday, 28 October 2011

What are internships?


Internships are student and graduate placements, aimed at giving them some experience before they join the employment market full-on. They are usually only a few months in duration, and are like more involved versions of work experience and shadowing, which you might have done during secondary school and sixth form.
However, they differ in a number of crucial ways:
  • You will probably be there for longer.
  • You are more likely to be assigned ‘real’ work, and develop real skills as a result.
  • You are more likely to get paid.
  • It probably will ‘look good on your CV’.
Of course, this isn’t absolute. Internships are used in very different ways by different employers in different industries. Some internships with big graduate employers in sectors such as banking are well paid, and are essential stepping stones to a place on their graduate schemes. Other internships, particularly in fashion and the media, may be unpaid.

Why bother?

Internships take time and effort. That time and effort could be spent studying, sleeping, having fun, or earning hard currency. However, you can get much out of them that will make them worthwhile:
  1. Find out whether you like the career – A lot of career choices are made on childhood aspirations, or other, similar uninformed decisions. Internships give you the time and insight needed to figure out whether the industry is really for you.
  2. Build up your experience – Employers like to take people on who can slip into a role with the minimum amount of training and acclimatisation. Experience not only involves the skills you have gained on a job, but also your comfort in an environment. Both can be developed on internships.
  3. Skip the job interviews – A lot of employers recruit directly from their internships to their graduate programme. They will have got to know you during the internship and will not need to interview you. As such you may be able to avoid the grad scheme competition altogether.
  4. Build up your contacts – Even if you don’t get a job off the back of your internship, you will certainly be in a position to develop a network of industry insiders. You can then use them as referees, or as a way to maintain your commercial awareness.

How do graduate internships differ?

In the current tough jobs market, graduates have increasingly been taking up internships after finishing their studies. Graduate internships can obviously last longer than student internships, which are limited to the length of the summer holidays. Sometimes graduate internships are unpaid, fuelling concerns that graduates are vulnerable to exploitation because of the intense competition for jobs. This is also controversial because anyone who is a worker in legal terms is entitled to the national minimum wage.

How to find internships

The good news about internships is that there are plenty of them out there.
  • Sector-specialist job boards and websites are also a good place to look.
  • Some organisations, particularly the larger ones, also advertise places on their own websites.
Speculative applications are unlikely to get you a paid and structured internship. Many organisations do take candidates on work experience placements, but these tend to be relatively short-term, and almost always unpaid.

How to choose

Internship applications take time, and it’s a good idea to target employers carefully. Some of the big graduate employers in areas such as finance break down their internship schemes into a number of different streams, so you may have to choose your preferred option when you apply. Here are some points to think about when you’re deciding what internship you want.
  1. Keep an eye on internship deadlines – For example, some finance internships close as early as November, and there are many deadlines around the end of December and early January.
  2. Find out what you will be doing – Not all big employers give interns proper work to do. The best internships are those which actually equip you with some of the skills you will need when you are doing the job. For this reason it is worth finding out what kind of jobs you will be doing beforehand.
  3. Really think about career progression – If you intend to use the internships to fast-track into the subsequent grad scheme you will need to choose the first step carefully. After this point it will be harder to change your mind.
  4. Take time and distance into account – If you aren’t used to working 9-5 days, or commuting for hours at a time, then this may be something to bear in mind. How willing are you to compromise your time?
Source: Ross, Targetjobs.co.uk, Thursday 27th October 2011

Tuesday, 9 August 2011

Unpaid internships at charities are about more than money

With volunteer interns becoming an inescapable fixture of many offices, a consensus has emerged around the need to offer an intern wage – with increasing focus on those organisations that fail to do so. A recent Guardian poll found just over 60% of respondents believed charities shouldn't offer unpaid internships, while Tanya de Grunwald, writing for Cif, criticised major unnamed charities for offering these internships.

Having been a volunteer intern for a leading UK charity, and now a paid intern for another, I am familiar with internships in the third sector. I fully support those campaigning for an intern wage and I do not wish to see unpaid internships continue among for-profit companies. However, volunteer charity internships are distinctly different, and I am one of a growing number who have benefitted from them.

Charities, by their nature, work for nobler causes than for-profit organisations. They put the interests of the vulnerable at the heart of their work and in difficult economic times they remain as important as ever. As charities face their own financial problems they are increasingly turning to volunteer interns to help continue the work they do. The objective at the heart of a charity's work means that interns are often directly helping to change lives; this is profoundly different to the work interns do elsewhere.

The level of commitment and the reasons why interns feel so strongly about certain causes can be hard to grasp. Nevertheless, undervaluing just how significant a motivation this can be is a mistake. It is a central factor in why they choose to invest their time in a charity internship, confident in the belief that they are not only making a wise career choice, but also making a real difference. Charities recognise the role volunteer interns play in helping to complete vast workloads, and in return offer support to further careers. I received excellent support from my manager who encouraged me to apply for paid positions, offered help in completing applications and practice for interviews.

Concerns that volunteer internships negatively impact on social mobility often lie at the heart of criticisms. Coming from a low-income family I know the difficulties inherent in pursuing certain careers without having the necessary contacts. When it comes to improving social mobility having equal access is as important as any other factor. On this note charities should be commended for running truly open recruitment processes. They offer anyone, from any school, from any university, the same opportunity as the next person.

Of course, being able to afford to undertake an internship is also a critical consideration. However, it is under-reported that volunteer interns can claim state benefits. I claimed jobseeker's allowance and I know of others who claimed housing benefit, but there is a worrying lack of information over what interns are entitled to. As youth unemployment reaches worrying heights we should be pressing to see volunteer internships put on an equal footing with any other welfare-to-work programme.

With all internships the ultimate question is whether they will help gain employment, so the quality of experience gained is crucial. Given the growing strains on resources charities are increasingly offering interns the chance to play key roles in major projects. Only by being involved in challenging work can interns develop the abilities and experience to showcase their skills to potential employers.

There are examples of interns who have worked unpaid for prolonged periods, but equally there are many success stories. Those interns I worked alongside have used their experiences to find paid employment. In light of the difficulties faced by those interning for long periods, as Tanya references, we may be better focusing on why, after interning, they haven't gained enough quality experience to find a permanent position. Internship schemes run by many leading charities should act as a template for others. They offer a consistent level of quality that reassures interns their time will be well spent.

Volunteer internships with charities are being engulfed in an ever narrowing debate, one too focused on the issue of pay. If charities were to end volunteer internships they would lose a vital stepping-stone for those wanting to work in the third sector. Interns, and groups representing them, should give equal attention to how we can improve the quality of internships, such as establishing a code of best practice, to ensure that interns gain the most from their time.

Source: Daniel Breslin, Guardian.co.uk, Sunday 7th August 2011

Thursday, 23 June 2011

Hard work doesn’t always pay

Does it ever make sense to contribute your labour free of charge? Matthew Lewis, then an out-of-work masters graduate, decided it did. Sadly, the introductions to employers promised in lieu of a salary never materialised. Instead, he spent six months interning at a business development consultancy making sales calls without pay or commission. “I did the same job as the guys who hired me – but they were salaried and I wasn’t,” he says.

His is not an isolated case. Reports abound of unfair practices. In February, a BBC documentary, Who Gets the Best Jobs, highlighted the prevalence of unpaid internships in the world of fashion PR. More recently, HSBC’s legal division was accused of nepotism and bolstering social inequality when a senior employee implied that his department limited work experience to the offspring of its own executives. In April, Nick Clegg, the UK deputy prime minister, said Whitehall would ban informal internships as part of a drive to improve social mobility.

Now the controversy has been stoked further by former intern Ross Perlin. In an exposé of questionable practices, Intern Nation: How to Earn Nothing and Learn Little in the Brave New Economy, he estimates there are 500,000 unpaid interns in the US, subsidising corporate America to the tune of $2bn a year.

However, stories of employers in fashion, politics, advertising and the media giving a leg-up to sons and daughters of acquaintances, or taking advantage of jobless graduates desperate for an inside track, paint a partial picture. For every alleged abuse there are also companies using internships to spot outstanding potential and beat competitors in the annual scramble for the best students. “For us, internships are an investment,” says François de Wazières, international recruitment director at L’Oréal, which recruits 3,400 interns worldwide – and pays them. He says they receive an average of about £1,500 ($2,400) in the UK and €1,400 ($2,000) in France.

Some interns at other companies receive non-financial rewards such as a phone after working on a campaign for a mobile phone brand. More important perhaps, practical experience can be a crucial springboard into employment as employers often see it as vital way to spot talent. The creative industries have a tradition of doing this. Like many agencies, marketing group Iris Worldwide hosts unpaid students and encourages them to brainstorm and work up ideas. “The thing [students] need most is experience and access to people in the industry,” says Ian Millner, the chief executive.

The counter-argument is that giving employers a free ride with un­paid labour props up companies that would otherwise go out of business, depresses wages and limits the career options for students who cannot afford to work free. Mr Perlin also argues that internships take away opportunities from regular workers.

When does give and take tip over into exploitation? In the UK, it boils down to whether an individual falls within one of four exemptions to the National Minimum Wage Act: volunteers; voluntary workers; work-shadowing/work experience; and students on course placements. Simply labelling someone an intern is not a get-out, says Alison Clements of Lewis Silkin, the law firm. What matters is whether “they are performing real work” and are obliged to work fixed hours.

Adam Foreman, a partner at Littler Mendelson, the law firm, says US law that guarantees interns a minimum wage is often ignored. Because “the interns are hoping to turn their internships into full-time jobs”, he says, transgressors are rarely hauled before the courts.

In Intern Nation, Mr Perlin dissects the employment practices of some of the world’s biggest corporations, inc­luding Disney, which he accuses of replacing “well-trained, decently compensated full-timers” with an army of low-paid interns. But for employers that approach recruitment strategically, internships are typically a cost – albeit one they hope will pay off in better, happier recruits.

By September this year, the UK division of PwC, the professional services firm, will have recruited about a third of its 2012 graduate intake from its summer vacation interns. Over the coming weeks, the group – selected through open competition – will be paid a graduate starting salary, meet clients, receive training and tackle a project. “Our recruitment tools can tell us whether a candidate is right for us,” says Richard Irwin, head of student recruitment. But without this kind of hands-on experience, “what the candidate might not know is whether we are right for them”.

All too often, says Rajeeb Dey, founder of Enternships, which arranges work placements in smaller businesses, employers fail to think through “what it means to have another person inside the company” and interns end up “running random errands”. They leave with a negative perception of the business that they may pass on to fellow students, including via websites such as Interns Anonymous.

Allowing interns “quality time away from their desks” so they can explore the organisation is important, says Jennifer Cook, a graduate rec­ruitment adviser at Linklaters, the law firm. For John Cordrey, a 2010 PwC tax intern, networking with other functions led to a change in his career plans. He is now set to join PwC’s corporate finance team instead of the tax division of a rival, whose internship was “less flexible”, he says.

As the expectations of students change, so must internships. Mr de Wazières says L’Oréal “sells” its international careers to graduates. Until 2009, all interns did their placements in their home country, which for internationally minded high-fliers was frustrating. “For the current generation of students, early international experience has a much bigger appeal.”

Do’s and don’ts for interns

● Check out your chances. Ask how many interns are made permanent. If the answer is very few, this may indicate that interns are seen as a cheap expedient, rather than as future employees.

● Establish the ratio of interns to staff. A high ratio can be a sign that the employer’s business model is unsustainable.

● Check the work will be relevant. Also check what training you will receive and who will manage you.

● Decide if the internship will develop your skills. Is it merely a job someone else would have to do? Ben Lyons, co-director of campaigners Intern Aware, says he has come across advertisements for “intern receptionists and cooks”.

● Don’t be lured into working set hours without pay. Working flat-out can leave you no time to search for salaried employment.

● Don’t be afraid to look at other options. Becky Heath, co-founder of campaign group Internocracy, says that volunteering may teach you more than a business that treats interns as free labour.

Source: Alicia Clegg, FT.com, Thursday 23rd June 2011

Friday, 27 May 2011

Third of government website internships 'unpaid'

Almost one in three internships on a government website for graduate job-hunters this year has been unpaid, a Freedom of Information request shows.

In a political row earlier this year Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg called for interns to be paid.

But the Graduate Talent Pool website, set up by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS), continues to offer many unpaid internships.

A BIS spokesman said businesses should be open and fair about what is offered.

University leavers face tough competition in the jobs market - and internships are seen as a way of getting a foot on the ladder.

But a Freedom of Information request, submitted by a graduate recruitment company called Give A Grad A Go, shows that 30% of the internships advertised so far this year on the government's official Graduate Talent Pool website have been unpaid.

Up to 6 May, more than 2,200 vacancies advertised on the website, out of a total of more than 7,600, were unpaid.

The website itself shows that out of the 2,239 vacancies currently available, only 1,235 are paid vacancies.

Among the unpaid internships are full-time posts lasting for several months, with a number of agencies appearing to use the website to recruit such unpaid interns.

The Graduate Talent Pool website was set up by the government as a way of connecting graduates with internships being offered by businesses.

But there have been criticisms over how internships can be misused as unpaid labour by some employers - and warnings about the need for them to comply with the minimum-wage regulations.

There have been particular warnings about the impact of the intern system on social mobility - with claims that it gives an unfair advantage to the well-connected and those who can afford to work without being paid or only receiving minimal expenses.

Mr Clegg highlighted his concerns in his social-mobility strategy - sparking a political row about his own access to work experience and differences of opinion with the prime minister.

"We want to improve understanding of the application of national minimum-wage legislation to internships and ensure that employers comply with it," said Mr Clegg's social-mobility proposals.

"Where an individual is entitled to the minimum wage they should receive it and we take failure to do so very seriously."

The Graduate Talent Pool website also warns employers that: "If an intern is effectively performing as a 'worker', then in most cases they will be entitled to the national minimum wage."

Cary Curtis, managing director of Give A Grad A Go, said: "Recent social-mobility debate between the prime minister and his deputy has highlighted the lack of a coherent approach to internships and work placements.

"Nick Clegg's new Social Mobility Strategy is a step in the right direction, as we believe all graduates should be treated as employees and paid accordingly, regardless of the position's label or their social standing.

"The word 'internship' carries no legal definition and therefore often leads to graduate exploitation," said Mr Curtis.

He also criticised the finding that the government department did not keep a record of how many graduates found a job through its internship website.

A spokesperson for the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills said: "We encourage businesses to offer internships openly and transparently and to provide financial support to ensure fair access.

"Some interns don't qualify for the national minimum wage and we encourage employers to pay reasonable out-of-pocket expenses in these cases."

A spokesman for the Deputy Prime Minister urged employers of interns to pay heed to minimum wage legislation, and to consider paying the minimum wage or out of pocket expenses to "ensure fair access".

"But this is as much about opportunity as it is about money," the spokesman said.

"Too often, such opportunities can only be taken by well off, well connected families," he said, adding that the deputy prime minister "welcomes schemes like the Graduate Talent Pool that provide an open and transparent means for people from any background to find the right opportunity for them".

Source: Sean Coughlan, BBC.co.uk, Friday 27th May 2011

Sunday, 24 April 2011

David Cameron backs right of middle-class families to give children a 'leg-up’ by exploiting their contacts — despite the practice being condemned by Nick Clegg.

In an interview published in The Telegraph, the Prime Minister said he would continue helping friends by offering their children internships, saying he was “very relaxed” about the situation. He even disclosed that he had invited a neighbour in for a work placement at his office.

The comments undermined his deputy, the Liberal Democrat leader, who recently said internships for the well-connected were one of the major forces preventing social mobility in Britain.

In the interview, Mr Cameron gave the most personal insight yet into his life as Prime Minister, just under a year after taking office.

He talked about a recent visit he made to the grave of his son, Ivan, who died in 2009 and said welcoming Baroness Thatcher to No10 was like an “out of body experience”. However, Mr Cameron admitted that not winning an outright majority at last year’s election had disappointed Tory supporters.

His decision to disagree publicly with one of Mr Clegg’s most high-profile policy interventions is likely to anger Liberal Democrats, who already resented Mr Cameron’s recent attacks in the debate on the Alternative Vote.

In the interview, Mr Cameron said it was “fine” to help people you knew. “I’ve got my neighbour coming in for an internship,” he said. “In the modern world, of course you’re always going to have internships and interns – people who come and help in your office who come through all sorts of contacts, friendly, political, whatever.

“I do that and I’ll go on doing that. I feel very relaxed about it.”

Earlier this month, Mr Clegg attacked the system that Mr Cameron has now endorsed, describing it as one of the barriers to poor Britons rising up the social hierarchy.

The Deputy Prime Minister criticised the system in which the “sharp-elbowed” and “well-connected” were the only ones with access to the top internships. He said professional life should be “about what you know, not who you know”.

Mr Cameron said Mr Clegg was “trying to make a fair point”, but happily admitted that as a young man he, like Mr Clegg, was helped out by his family connections, getting experience in his father’s stockbrokers. He called that break a “definite leg-up internship”.

Source: Telegraph.co.uk, Friday 22nd April 2011